Unlawful Pay Deductions (UK): How to Challenge Them
Updated 27 September 2026 · Sources listed below
Unlawful pay deductions in the UK are more tightly defined than many employers assume. If money has come out of your wages and nobody can point to the law, a written contract term you were given in advance, or your own prior written agreement, you may have a claim for an unlawful deduction from wages — and the time limit for acting on it is short.
The short answer
Under section 13 of the Employment Rights Act 1996, an employer can only deduct from your wages where the deduction is required or authorised by law (such as tax and National Insurance), is authorised by a term of your contract that you were given in writing — or told about in writing — before the deduction, or where you agreed to it in writing beforehand. GOV.UK also lists recovering an earlier overpayment of wages or expenses, and pay for time on strike. If none of these applies, ask for the money back in writing. If that fails, you can bring a claim in the employment tribunal, normally after notifying Acas for early conciliation.
Contents
When an employer can lawfully deduct
GOV.UK lists the situations in which a deduction is allowed. Anything outside them is where a challenge starts. The contract route is narrower than it sounds: the term must be in writing and given to you, or its effect explained to you in writing, before the deduction is made.
The lawful routes
- It is required or allowed by law — for example income tax, National Insurance or student loan repayments
- You agreed to it in writing
- Your contract says the employer can make it
- It recovers an earlier overpayment of wages or expenses
- You did not work because of strike or other industrial action
- It is a statutory payment to a public authority, or a court has ordered it
Consent has to come first
Section 13 says an agreement or consent you give does not authorise a deduction for conduct or an event that happened before you gave it. The same applies to a contract change: a new term does not authorise a deduction for something that happened before the change took effect. So a form you were asked to sign after a till shortage or a damaged item does not, on its own, make a deduction for that shortage or damage lawful.
Deductions worth questioning
None of these is automatically unlawful — the test above decides it — but they are the ones to check carefully against your contract and anything you signed, and when.
Check these against the rules
- Till shortages, breakages or stock losses where nothing in writing allowed it
- Clawback of training, uniform or equipment costs
- Deductions from final pay when you leave — check what your contract says
- Deductions described only as 'adjustment' or with no description at all
- Deductions that take your pay below the National Minimum Wage, which GOV.UK says is generally not allowed except for listed items such as tax, National Insurance and overpayments
Extra protection for retail workers
If you work in retail, GOV.UK says your employer cannot take more than 10% of your gross pay in each pay period to cover shortfalls such as cash or stock losses. A larger amount has to be spread over several pay periods. The exception is your final pay when you leave, from which the employer can take the full outstanding amount.
Your payslip is evidence
Employees are entitled to a payslip showing earnings before and after deductions, and the amount of any deductions that change from one pay day to the next, such as tax and National Insurance. Fixed deductions must be explained either on the payslip or in a separate written statement given beforehand. If a deduction is not shown or explained, ask for it in writing.
Time limits — and the change on 1 October 2026
Chasing payroll informally does not pause the clock. Notifying Acas for early conciliation does, provided you do it within the time limit. After early conciliation ends you have at least one month from the date you receive the certificate to make your claim.
The deadlines
- The time limit runs from the date of the deduction — or, for a series of deductions, from the last one
- Where the time limit starts before 1 October 2026: three months less one day
- Where it starts on or after 1 October 2026: six months less one day
- A tribunal generally cannot consider deductions from wages paid more than two years before the claim is made
- You normally have to notify Acas before you can make a tribunal claim
UK unlawful deduction letter template
Edit this template with your facts, dates, and requested outcome before sending.
Subject: Deduction from wages — [your name], payslip dated [date] Dear [Payroll / HR], My payslip dated [date] shows a deduction of £[amount] described as [description on payslip / no description]. [If more than one: Similar deductions were made on [dates], totalling £[amount].] I have not agreed in writing to this deduction, and I have not been given a written contract term that allows it. [If relevant: I was asked to sign an agreement on [date], after the event the deduction relates to.] Please either: 1. Repay £[amount] by [date — for example 14 days from this letter], and confirm in writing that the deduction will not be repeated; or 2. Tell me in writing the specific legal provision, contract term or written agreement you rely on, with a copy of it. Please also send me an itemised payslip for [period] if the deduction is not shown on it. I am raising this now because of the time limits that apply to unlawful deduction claims, and I would prefer to resolve it directly with you. Yours sincerely, [Your Name] [Employee number, if any]
Common mistakes to avoid
- Not recording the exact amount, date and description of each deduction
- Signing a retrospective agreement without realising it may not cover past events
- Assuming a payroll error will correct itself while the time limit runs
- Arguing that the deduction is unfair instead of asking what authorised it
- Waiting for an internal grievance to finish before checking the tribunal deadline
- Overlooking separate shortfalls such as unpaid holiday or notice pay
Next steps
- 1List every deduction with its date, amount and payslip description
- 2Find your contract and anything you signed about deductions, and note the dates
- 3Write to payroll asking for repayment or the written basis for the deduction
- 4Ask for an itemised payslip if the deduction is not shown or explained
- 5Work out your time limit from the date of the last deduction
- 6Contact Acas about early conciliation if the money is not repaid in time
Sources
- GOV.UK — Deductions from your pay
- Employment Rights Act 1996, section 13 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Employment Rights Act 1996, section 23 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Acas — Employment tribunal time limits
- Acas — How early conciliation works
Rules and deadlines change. Check the official source before relying on a date or amount.
Generate your letter now
WorkRight.AI drafts clear, structured letters based on your specific situation — housing, work, consumer, billing and more. You keep full control — review and edit every word before sending.
Draft your pay dispute letter →Not sure this is the right letter for your situation? Check your situation first